Big Fish – The Other Palace, London

Book: John August, based on the novel by Daniel Wallace
Music and Lyrics: Andrew Lippa
Director: Nigel Harman
Reviewer: Scott Matthewman

For many musicals, going a full fifteen minutes without any songs can seem like a drag; at the top of the show, it can seem like the kiss of death. Yet forBig Fish, The Other Palace’s latest premiere, its song-free start only serves to enhance the family relationships at the heart of Andrew Lippa’s musical.

tell-us-block_editedThe headline performer of this London version of the 2013 Broadway musical is US TV and stage star Kelsey Grammer. By opening as if part of a straight play, John August’s book allows Grammer to really sell the character of Edward Bloom, a man whose grand gestures of storytelling threaten to overshadow the marriage of his son, Will (Matthew Seadon-Young) to Josephine (Frances McNamee).

But then fate intervenes, and the wedding gets overshadowed by Edward collapsing of a stroke. And as he is treated in hospital, the stories he told of his early days come to life before our eyes, intermingling with his family as they come to terms with their patriarch’s mortality.

That this is a story of father and son estrangement and bonding perhaps explain why Clare Burt’s mother, Sandra, remains one of the few characters who feels underdeveloped; August and composer Andrew Lippa are concerned more with Edward and Will, along with the younger Edward’s relationships with cave-dwelling giant Karl (Dean Nolan) and Forbes Masson’s circus master Amos, than with the women of the piece.

But while the men are rather better drawn than the women, the romance and pursuit of love are such strong themes here that such gender disparity becomes easy to forgive. A huge part of that romance is down to Jamie Muscato as Grammer’s youngeralter ego. As Edward zips from story to fantastical story – projected as a human cannonball across huge distances, or throwing himself of a poison dart and changing the course of the war – Muscato’s effortless charms sell Edward’s cheery way of mixing fact and fiction.

Lippa’s songs include the bright and breezy, most notably the WW2 close harmony pasticheRed, White and Truewhich opens Act II. But the greatest musical achievements, of many, here are the song’s big romantic ballads, fromTime Stopsas Edward and Sandra meet for the first time toDaffodils, as they mark their love with bouquets, and eventually fields, of the blooms.

Big Fish’s score, one of the best to emerge from Broadway in the last several years, is complemented with some occasionally astonishing choreography by Liam Steel. A circus sequence with Muscato leaping through hula hoops is a particular highlight, beautifully executed by all concerned. Further complementing the show’s romanticism, Tom Rogers’s set design incorporates projections that genuinely illuminate the storytelling.

With comic supporting turns from Masson and Nolan in particular, there is plenty to laugh at withinBig Fish. But the overriding emotion is one of heart-wrenching devotion to one’s parents; of the power of mythic fairytales; of finding heroism where one least expects it.

Since its relaunch as a home for new musical theatre, The Other Palace’s headline shows have not always lived up to the venue’s promise. That’s important because the commercial success of the big auditorium’s shows help fund all the development of new works in which the venue is investing. WithBig Fish, The Other Palace may just have found that perfect combination of commercial success and technically superb work. One would certainly be hard-pressed to find a more emotional, more satisfying work on the London stage right now.

Runs until 31 December 2017 | Image: Tristram Kenton

Review Overview

The Reviews Hub Score

Emotionally superb

Show More
Photo of The Reviews Hub - London

The Reviews Hub - London

The Reviews Hub London is under the acting editorship of Richard Maguire. The Reviews Hub was set up in 2007. Our mission is to provide the most in-depth, nationwide arts coverage online.

Related Articles


  1. Good to read an true appraisal of this wondrous show. Can’t quite get to grips with some of the other critics views. P.

  2. Well that’s the first honest review of the show I’ve seen. As Paul Phear says, what is going on with the reviews? The response throughout the show and at the end made it clear enough that everyone in the theatre LOVED it.
    A few of my friends have been – we’ve all reviewed shows professionally for press and TV and attended hundreds of theatre productions each – and amazed by the dishonest reviews. Tristram’s review here is bang on the money and totally representative of the audience experience IMHO.

Back to top button
The Reviews Hub